The Whale Controversy: What to Know


Tright here’s loads of delicate subtext shrouding Darren Aronofsky’s The Whale, which hits U.S. theaters on Dec. 9.

Based mostly on Samuel D. Hunter’s 2012 off-Broadway play of the identical title, The Whale follows Brendan Fraser as Charlie, a reclusive 600-pound homosexual English instructor grieving the dying of his associate, whereas making an attempt to reconcile along with his estranged daughter Ellie (Stranger Issues’ Sadie Sink) earlier than he dies.

The A24 psychological drama—the Black Swan filmmaker’s first film since 2017’s Mom!—has garnered loads of consideration for revitalizing Fraser’s profession with a number one position that’s producing Oscar buzz. However the movie has additionally been accused of fatphobia, with some saying using a fatsuit turns Fraser’s character right into a spectacle. Right here’s what to know in regards to the discourse that has surrounded The Whale since its debut on the Venice Movie Pageant in September.

Fraser’s long-awaited comeback

On the top of his reputation within the 1990s, Fraser starred in Airheads (1994), George of the Jungle (1997), and The Mummy (1999). However because the century turned, he regularly retreated from the highlight.

In 2018, Fraser informed GQ that the trajectory of his profession was affected by a divorce, the dying of his mom, bodily well being points, and an alleged assault by Hollywood International Press Affiliation (HFPA) president Philip Berk at a HFPA-hosted luncheon on the Beverly Hills Lodge in 2003. Whereas Berk recalled groping Fraser in what he known as jest in his memoir, calling the allegations “a complete fabrication,” Fraser stated the alleged assault was extra sinister.

“I felt in poor health. I felt like a little bit child. I felt like there was a ball in my throat. I assumed I used to be going to cry,” Fraser recalled, including that he was impressed to talk about the expertise after witnessing the braveness of his associates through the #MeToo motion, which started to ripple by Hollywood in 2017. Fraser additionally alleged that the HFPA hardly ever invited him again to the Golden Globes after the incident, however the group maintains that “his profession declined by no fault of ours.”

Why is The Whale being accused of fatphobia?

A number of the movie’s critics consider it perpetuates drained tropes of fats folks as struggling, chronically depressed and binge consuming. Some have additionally known as Fraser’s transformation into Charlie, with using a fatsuit, dehumanizing, mentioning that fats folks can’t take off their weight on the finish of the day in the best way the actors can, and that fats actors had been ignored when casting the position.

Fraser informed Vainness Truthful that Charlie was dropped at life after 5 or 6 hours in a make-up chair, utilizing a metamorphic prosthetic swimsuit that was “not precisely snug” and carrying round 50 to 300 further kilos throughout varied scenes. Fraser added that “the torso piece was nearly like a straight jacket” and he usually wanted mobility help from the crew.

These painstaking efforts taken to emulate Charlie’s bodily form left some plus-size, homosexual actors questioning why Fraser—a heterosexual actor who weighs a lot lower than his character—secured the position.

Daniel Franzese, an actor greatest recognized for his position as Damien in Imply Women (2004), informed Folks he and different bigger homosexual actors are usually ignored for roles, even after they have the direct life expertise. He stated he was “conflicted” as a result of he loves Fraser and needs him to have his second however the casting alternative represents a wider subject.

“To lastly have an opportunity to be in a status movie that is perhaps award-nominated, the place tales about individuals who appear like us are being informed? That’s the dream,” Franzese stated. “So after they go time and time once more and solid somebody like Brendan Fraser, me and the opposite huge queer guys, we’re like, ‘What the…?’ We will’t take it!”

Author and Upkeep Section podcaster Aubrey Gordon additionally expressed her disappointment within the movie throughout a collection of tweets in September that known as the film out for having a “staggeringly” anti-fat premise. Whereas she hadn’t but seen it, she touched on the stageplay’s plot wherein the story opens with Charlie worrying that he could have a coronary heart assault after masturbating to homosexual pornography.

In a follow-up statement, Gordon tweeted, “If the one approach you may ‘humanize’ a really fats individual is to observe them humiliated, terrified, ashamed & killed off in a stereotypically stigmatizing approach, it’s time to do some severe reflecting.”

How have the solid and crew responded to criticism?

Fraser has stated that he sees the movie and his character in another way. He informed Folks that utilizing a fatsuit and prosthetics was “one of many extra exacting methods” to create an correct character. He added that Charlie’s costume would “respect the legal guidelines of gravity and physics” in a approach that’s distinctive in comparison with earlier motion pictures’ efforts which have usually served up mocking or comedic portrayals of fats our bodies.

Charlie was dropped at life with the assistance of make-up results specialist Adrien Morot, who used a 3D printer and digital sculpture to create Fraser’s fatsuit. Aronofsky maintains that Charlie has been portrayed with empathy and understanding, telling Selection that loads of his colleagues in leisure have created “one-note” motion pictures that “depict weight problems with crude jokes.”

He added that they tried to solid an actor who would “pull off” the feelings of Charlie’s character, however the well being issues that may accompany extreme weight problems made it “an inconceivable position to fill with an actual individual coping with these points.”

The title The Whale is a double entendre: On one hand, it refers to Charlie’s obsession with an English paper on the basic novel Moby Dick. However Hunter, the author of the unique play, additionally informed Selection that it “intentionally pokes at some folks’s prejudices.”

He added: “I wasn’t stunned by the blowback, due to the historical past of the best way that weight problems is handled on movie. And we reside in cynical and reactionary instances.”

What position have fatsuits performed onscreen?

From the unflattering characterization of “Fats Monica” in Pals to John Travolta embracing a 30-pound fats swimsuit to play Edna Turnblad in Hairspray (2007), fatsuits have traditionally been used as a comedy gadget to encourage viewers to chuckle at obese characters. Tv and movie have largely moved on from frequent use of fats fits, however they haven’t disappeared totally.

Final yr, Sarah Paulson wore a fatsuit in American Crime Story to painting Linda Tripp—the lady whose recorded conversations with Monica Lewinsky had been pivotal in President Invoice Clinton’s intercourse scandal. However Paulson did specific some regrets about taking over area in a task that would have solid a plus-size actor.

“It’s very exhausting for me to speak about this with out feeling like I’m making excuses,” Paulson informed the LA Instances. “There’s loads of controversy round actors and fatsuits, and I feel that controversy is a reputable one. I feel fatphobia is actual. I feel pretending in any other case causes additional hurt.” Nonetheless Paulson insisted that actors can convey one thing past their bodily self to a task.

Extra lately, Emma Thompson sparked additional debate on the difficulty when she stepped right into a fatsuit to rework into the formidable headteacher Miss Trunchbull in Matthew Warchus’ adaptation of stage present Roald Dahl’s Matilda The Musical, which premiered on the London Movie Pageant in October and in U.S. theaters on Dec. 9, and hits Netflix on Christmas.

Some discovered the portrayal to be “dehumanizing and degrading,” whereas others stated placing on costumes is “what actors do.” Thompson’s position additionally led to debates on whether or not actors ought to quickly achieve weight to precisely tackle these roles, or whether or not it was time to begin casting actual plus-size actors as a substitute.

On Fraser’s half, his position in The Whale has made him one of many frontrunners on this awards season’s Finest Actor race. Time will inform whether or not the controversy is sufficient to hurt that marketing campaign, and whether or not it raises consciousness on a path towards broader change within the business.

Extra Should-Reads From TIME

Write to Armani Syed at

Supply hyperlink


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here