Instantly after the decision was introduced, Smith’s household shortly left the courtroom. The prosecuting lawyer, Montgomery County Chief Deputy Commonwealth’s Lawyer Patrick Jensen, declined remark and referred inquiries to his boss, Commonwealth’s Lawyer Mary Pettitt.
The jury started deliberations after closing arguments ended shortly earlier than three p.m.
Prosecutors had earlier instructed the jury that Etute, then 18, grew to become enraged and fatally beat Smith when he found Smith was a person. One of many prosecutors mentioned at closing arguments Friday that Etute gave totally different variations of occasions to police and the jury, and that the cost could have been sufficient for him to vary his testimony.
“He has an incredible quantity driving on this trial,” Jensen had mentioned throughout his closing argument hours earlier Friday, The Roanoke Occasions reported.
Protection lawyer Jimmy Turk instructed the jurors earlier Friday that the commonwealth’s proof was circumstantial, whereas the protection’s proof, which included the testimony of Etute, was direct.
Turk additionally mentioned Smith was “controlling the whole atmosphere and the whole episode.” He added that Smith had “demanded that or not it’s darkish” and had hidden a knife beneath his mattress “in case there was one thing awry.”
Turk additionally argued that police didn’t ask Etute important questions on Smith’s knife or Etute’s concern whereas within the condo, two questions whose solutions might have proven whether or not Etute was afraid for his life and performing in self-defense.
In taking the stand earlier within the week, Etute had testified that he felt “violated” when he found that the Tinder match he believed to be a girl was really a person.
In his testimony Thursday, Etute had testified that Smith reached for what Etute thought was a gun. Smith didn’t personal a gun, however police reported discovering a knife between the person’s mattress and field spring.
Etute mentioned he punched Smith 5 occasions and kicked him to realize time to flee the condo.
Jensen had maintained that Etute had not acted in self-defense. He argued that after Etute punched Smith and Smith fell to the ground, there was “no means” Smith might have reached a weapon beneath his mattress.
“He might by no means attain a gun from there,” Jensen mentioned.
Jensen recalled the testimony of medical expert Dr. Amy Tharp, who Jensen mentioned testified Smith had been the sufferer of a “brutal beating.”
Jensen mentioned that whereas Etute was sporting flip-flops on the time of the encounter, these sneakers have been hooked up to a “large individual” and a “sturdy individual.” He in contrast Etute, an “elite faculty athlete,” to Smith, who weighed 153 kilos (slightly below 70 kilograms).
“That’s an enormous disparity,” Jensen mentioned.